There are not many religions or spiritual paths active in humanity today which I would say I oppose out of hand. There are facets of many religions and spiritual paths which strike me as singularly destructive and damaging to people, to humanity as a whole, however.
Evangelism and mission work is one of those facets.
I wrote a few days ago about how easily the act of helping or accepting help can be twisted into manipulation, and mission work is just about the most blatant example. I have a really hard time with the idea that any spiritual outcome is so important that it justifies holding a real need in front of another human like bait, luring them to your beliefs.
It didn’t take much searching to find a blog post by someone committed to missionary work, talking about their experience and drive to engage in it. The post goes in depth about the motivations for mission work which, clearly stated, boils down to the need to convert others and turn them from their existing spiritual beliefs in order to save their eternal souls. There is no beating around the bush about it, either. The fact that the missions experience detailed in the post was to earthquake-devastated Nepal and the idea that we should be called to lift others out of poverty and starvation were only mentioned in passing. The physical help, the actual work of healing the sick and feeding the hungry and housing the homeless is just a means to an end.
How can we not be troubled by the idea that, when huge disasters happen in the world, groups of people swoop in to tell the victims that the state of their eternal souls is far more important than their physical life? How is it okay to provide help to those who obviously need it and, in the process, try to undermine the spiritual underpinnings of their lives?
The blog post I linked above had one particularly troubling passage which described how, because the writer felt uncomfortable “darkness” while in a Buddhist chanting room, he decided that his long-held opinion that other world religions were harmless was clearly wrong. This uncomfortable feeling reinforced a conviction to use the needs of the world to manipulate others into listening to religious propaganda.
Help should be provided when needed, when we are able to provide it, and never as a means to a different end. Feed people, clothe people, give people shelter, teach people skills not because they might then come to agree with the way you think or because you get a reward out of it, but because they need it. Simply that. No strings attached.Tags: aid, beliefs, charity, christianity, giving, manipulation, missions, motivation, religion, spirituality, values
Ultimate Blogger Theme By Buywptemplates